Hospital held liable for failure to provide life-support ambulance
The Delhi State Consumer Commission ordered Metro Hospital & Heart Institute to pay ₹15 lakh for failing to arrange a life-support ambulance and doctor for a critical stroke patient's transfer, causing long-term disability.

A hospital's failure to provide a life-support ambulance for a critical patient transfer has resulted in a landmark compensation order. The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission directed Metro Hospital & Heart Institute to pay ₹15 lakh for deficiency in service after a patient suffered a debilitating stroke during a delayed inter-facility move.
On November 13, 2013, patient Suresh Kumar was taken to Metro Hospital in Lajpat Nagar with acute breathing difficulty. An echocardiogram revealed a clot obstructing his artificial aortic valve, a legacy of dual valve replacement surgery he had undergone in 2008. The hospital advised transferring him to another facility for specialized care but then failed to arrange an appropriately equipped ambulance or a doctor to accompany him. His family alleged nearly five hours were lost before they secured independent transport to Vimhans Hospital.
The patient's condition deteriorated catastrophically during this period. By November 15, a dislodged clot had traveled to his brain, causing a major stroke. Suresh Kumar's right side was paralysed and he lost his speech. He remains unable to speak, read, write, or earn a living.
Commission's findings on hospital liability
The Commission, in a judgment authored by Justice Sangita Dhingra Sehgal and Member Pinki on November 6, 2026, made a clear distinction between medical treatment and post-treatment care. It exonerated the treating cardiologist, Dr. Samanjoy Mukharjee, of medical negligence. Relying on expert opinions from GB Pant Hospital and the Medical Council of India, the Commission found the use of the clot-busting drug streptokinase was standard protocol and that stroke was a known complication for which high-risk consent had been taken.
However, the Commission held the hospital itself squarely liable for the transportation failure. It stated a hospital's duty of care does not end after consultation or treatment within its premises. The bench found Metro Hospital had miserably failed in its elementary responsibility to arrange emergency transport, calling it a serious dereliction of duty and a failure to adhere to elementary standards of reasonable care. The Commission emphasized that emergency facilities like ambulance and medical personnel are not optional services and that patients cannot be expected to arrange essential medical infrastructure in emergencies.
The legal basis and awarded compensation
Citing the Supreme Court judgment in Balram Prasad v. Kunal Saha, the Commission affirmed a higher standard of care for premier hospitals. It ruled the failure was not a mere procedural lapse but a clear deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. The hospital's complete silence on this failure in its defence further weighed against it.
The Commission partly allowed Complaint Case No. 1146 of 2015, which was filed by Suresh Kumar through his wife in 2015. It ordered Metro Hospital & Heart Institute to pay ₹15 lakh as compensation for the mental agony and distress caused by its service failure. It also levied ₹50,000 in litigation costs for the protracted legal battle that lasted over a decade. The treating doctor had been proceeded against ex parte in 2016.
Payment deadline and interest
The hospital must pay the total compensation and costs within two months, by January 6, 2027. Failure to meet this deadline will incur interest at a rate of 9% per annum, calculated from the date the complaint was filed in 2015 until the full payment is made.





